We want your vehicle! Get the best value for your trade-in!

Best Choice Auto
1200 E Columbia St
Evansville, IN 47711

(812) 421-8861


C. Phelps - 2011 Dodge Durango Crew

"Would recommend this place to anyone! Robert helped us get our Durango & it’s been a pleasure working with him!" -C. Phelps

S. Ottey - 2018 Hyundai Elantra SEL

"Robert is the best salesman I’ve ever met, he’s so professional got me a car within 2 hours. He'll help out with everything the best way he can, first timers go here you won't regret it, robs the best thank you so much." -S. Ottey

S. Kinison - 2013 Dodge Durango SXT

"Robert was awesome and got me in the exact car I came in for I couldn’t have asked for a better person to get me in a vehicle." -S. Kinison

M. Schmitt - 2013 Ford Explorer Sport

"I purchased a vehicle at BEST CHOICE AUTO, after I was in an accident that resulted in a total loss of my vehicle at the fault of someone else. Due to it being someone else’s fault, waiting for their insurance resulted in a very delayed response. Having a vehicle in your name and trying to buy another with not-so-great credit can be difficult. But we found an absolute STEAL , AND I was approved with my not-so-great credit. They have not only provided phenomenal service at the time of the purchase but have followed up with us since then. I would HIGHLY HIGHLY RECOMMEND BEST CHOICE AUTO. THEY TRULY LIVE UP TO THEIR NAME!!!!! ~Happy Customer" - M. Schmitt

A. Blair - 2013 Chrysler Town & Country Limited

"We are extremely happy with our vehicle. We received a great deal for less and got exactly what we were looking for. Robert was amazing, stayed late so we could check the vehicle out, and then did everything he could to get us in our new vehicle asap. Addressed our questions and concerns one way or another and made signing as smooth as possible." -A. Blair

K. Hall - 2014 Buick LaCrosse

"Very professional, they worked with my budget and they have high quality cars." -K. Hall

T. Schoenbaechler - 2015 Toyota Camry SE

"Had a great experience with Best Choice Auto if you need a new car go check them out very friendly and very helpful in putting my son a car thank you." -T. Schoenbaechler

D. Washington - 2015 Ford Escape SE

"Robert got me in a vehicle with good payments and worked with my financial state. Super simple process took about 2 hours from start to finish. Very pleased with everything." -D. Washington

T. Tucker - 2015 Chrysler Town & Country Platinum

"Robert was great, very professional and helpful so I could get the vehicle I needed. Thank you Robert loving my van." -T. Tucker

A. Richardson - 2007 Lexus IS 250

"8 years ago, I bought a silver Lexus SC300 from these guys and had a great experience. Fast forward to yesterday, and I’m back here for a silver Lexus IS250, expecting the same.

Robert was great to deal with from start to finish! We spoke on the phone a bit starting a week prior, and once I got to physically look at the car, it was quick and painless. I don’t think we were there 30min if you don’t count the test drive. He got me the term, payment, and coverage I wanted, down to the dollar.

I couldn’t be happier! Thanks Robert! Looking at the pics, it’s impressive to see how the dealership has grown in the last decade. Good for you guys!" -A. Richardson

J. Bourland - 2011 Jeep Grand Cherokee Limited

"Robert was very friendly and patient, he made our buying experience enjoyable, quick, and painless!" -J. Bourland

V. Ricketts - 2014 GMC Sierra 1500 SLE

"Robert was a great salesman. Got exactly what we wanted without any hassel. He went above and beyond to get us the price and payment that was in our budget. Cant say enough about the experience. Will be coming back for future vehicles." -V. Ricketts

L. Mangin - 2013 Lexus RX 350

"Absolutely the best! Sales people listen to what you need in a vehicle and work hard to deliver. I just purchased a beautiful used Lexus that is a dream. I highly recommend Best Choice Auto." -L. Mangin

C. Smith - 2013 Toyota Camry XLE

"They are very helpful and made getting a vehicle easy. I would definitely recommend them to anyone based on their stellar customer support and high quality vehicles for good value on their lot." -C. Smith

S. Newberry - 2016 Hyundai Sonata Sport

"Great customer service, great prices, great vehicles. Highly recommend!!" -S. Newberry

Z. Powell - 2009 Dodge Nitro SLT

"I got a 2009 Dodge Nitro that I really like and they were upfront and honest about everything. And the salesman did a really good job on getting me the best price. I've already recommended this place to multiple people because of the good experience I had!" -Z. Powell

K. Heil - 2012 Nissan Rogue SV

"Enjoyed working wth Best Choice Auto to purchase a replacement car for our family!" -K. Heil

M. Mason - 2003 Buick LeSabre Limited

"I originally looked up best auto because of their location and it was a pretty nice looking business. Now I did this online and had looked at cars under $10,000 and of course I found a couple I liked but I'm being very conservative at the moment, ended up with a Buick. And they worked real hard at getting me credit approval, and me and my phone for doing as much as I can do to help myself but they didn't give up and neither did I. I now own a nice looking, well running car that was the purpose of me going to see them and I think they did an excellent job and we're very friendly." -M.Mason

S. Madi - 2016 Honda Odyssey EX-L

"Never felt pressured from moment we walked in. Robert was easy to work with and worked with us to find a great price for our Honda Odyssey. Would definitely recommend this dealership." -S.Madi

D. Harvey - 2015 Chevrolet Camaro LT

"Just to say the least this company has helped me with a lot ...very patient and understanding.if you wanna learn about things before you sign .. Well ask questions. Try not to feel down about something you don't know. So I give my ups to them.. Thanks again" -D. Harvey

C. Ray - 2009 Toyota Highlander Limited Sport

"Good place to get a vehicle, affordable payments for good vehicles! Thanks guys!" -C. Ray

T. Jordan - 2007 Chevrolet Suburban 1500 LTZ

"Trustworthy staff with dependable vehicles. We are return customers, and will continue to be, and highly recommend them! Everyone is kind, helpful, and honest. Which tends to lack most places. There has never been any pressure, tricks, or gimmicks." -T. Jordan

A. Evans - 2015 Ford Fusion SE

"Robert and the staff at Best Choice could not have been more helpful and thoughtful in going through the car buying process. Very pleasant experience in what could understandably be a stressful one." A. Evans

B. Pigman - 2016 Hyundai Tucson Limited

"I love my new car they were very easy to work with and got me approved quickly.." - B. Pigman

B. Simon - 2011 Ford Explorer XLT

"Our family has purchased 3 vehicles from Best Choice Auto. We keep going back for the excellent customer service we always receive. Best Choice Auto has always went above and beyond our expectations. They are professional, honest, and provide great service." - B. Simon

D. York - 2012 Honda Odyssey Touring

"Pete, our salesman was amazing!!! Thank you for making our buying experience stress free!!!!" - D. York 

R. Cimbalnik - 2011 Nissan Armada Platinum Sport

"After going to another used car lot and being treated poorly I went to Best Choice Auto. Just want to thank Robert and everyone else at Best Choice that made buying a car a pleasant experience! They have a wide selection and a great staff! They answered all of my questions and were very helpful. My next vehicle will definitely come from Best Choice!" - R. Cimbalnik

D. Suggs - 2016 Nissan Maxima SR

"Very easy process!! Most of my family and friends have also bought a car from here. They were very helpful. 10/10 would recommend" - D. Suggs

D. Derr - 2016 Chevrolet Equinox LTZ

"I am so happy with the attention, superior service, all the salesmen are very professional, and friendly... love my car and would not hesitate to refer my friends and family to Best Choice Auto..." - D. Derr

K. Greenwalt - 2008 Toyota Sienna XLE

"Robert was an amazing salesman. He asked me all of the right questions to put me in the vehicle of my dreams. I needed a family van and let me just say best choice auto provided. This is the second time I have purchased a vehicle from them. I just now traded in my first vehicle from them 5 years later for something that will better accommodate my family. So if you are looking for a long term vehicle Best Choice Auto is the place to go!" - K. Greenwalt